TORONTO – TD Bank (TSX:TD) has lowered its estimates for economic growth this year in most of Canada's provinces — saying the United States, Europe and Asia are weaker than expected and households are more cautious than before.
It says Alberta and Saskatchewan will continue to lead the other provinces in economic growth this year, but the pace will fall below 3%.
TD is estimating 2012 growth will less than 2% in the other eight provinces.
In most provinces, the new TD estimate is below the outlook it issued in July, with the exception of Manitoba and Prince Edward Island.
"In Europe, while a dramatic escalation in the financial crisis has been avoided and mechanisms aimed at preventing such an outcome have been agreed upon, risk levels remain high," the report says.
It adds that the U.S. economy has been recovering at a "disappointing pace" and exports to Canada's largest foreign customer have been constrained by the high value of Canada's dollar relative to the U.S. currency.
"Moreover, China's soft landing and the maturation of growth in many emerging market countries have set limits to what had appeared to be almost boundless demand — a development that has not been lost on commodity markets."
In Canada, TD notes the federal and provincial governments have launched extensive efforts to restrain their spending and home prices have begun to come down in after years of rapid growth in some markets.
It suggested Canadian households across the country — particularly in Ontario — are being more cautious than previously expected.
"Construction of commercial properties (in Ontario) is brimming and the housing market has maintained its upward path despite signs of some overvaluation in its major markets, especially in the Greater Toronto Area."
"At the same time, however, households have shown increased caution, as evidenced by weakening retail sales gains and a reduction in the pace of debt accumulation."
The report says housing markets will face different outlooks depending on the region, with the Prairies likely to be "largely unscathed" and the major markets in Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver to show declines.
"The varying residential market conditions will exacerbate growth differentials given that housing is a large driver of consumer spending," the report says.
TD adds that its forecasts for 2013 and 2014 are looking more positive, although it expects growth will continue to be modest.
The revised forecast calls for Saskatchewan to have the fastest economic growth of any province, with an increase of 2.9% over last year. Alberta is in the No. 2 spot at 2.8% projected growth this year.
Newfoundland and Labrador is at the other end of the spectrum, with its growth falling dramatically from 2.8% last year to 0.9% in 2012 — the lowest among the 10 provinces.
Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia — the three most populous provinces — are now projected to have 2012 growth of 1.9%, 1.5% and 1.7% respectively.
Manitoba's growth is projected to be 1.9% — matching Ontario's — while P.E.I. will lead the Atlantic provinces at 1.8%, followed by Nova Scotia (1.3 %) and New Brunswick (1.0%) and Newfoundland (0.9%).
For most provinces, TD is forecasting stronger growth in 2013 than this year and further improvement in 2014.
Newfoundland's growth in 2013, bolstered by its oil and gas resources, is projected to be 2.3% followed by 2.5% in 2014. The growth in the other three energy-rich provinces — Alberta, Saskatchewan and British Columbia — is estimated at 3.1%, 3.0% and 1.9% respectively.
Ontario is one of only two provinces that are expected to see slower economic growth next year, falling to 1.8% from 1.9%. The other laggard is expected to be P.E.I., with 1.4% growth down from 1.8%.
The projected 2013 growth rates for the other provinces are: Nova Scotia, 2.0%; New Brunswick, 1.4%, Quebec, 1.7%; Manitoba, 2.1%.